|
| Author |
Message |
Sandhusker
Rancher
Joined: 10 Feb 2005
Posts: 12283
Location: Nebraska
|
 Posted: Mon Sep 08, 2008 6:41 am Post subject: |
 |
|
| nonothing wrote: |
| Sandhusker wrote: |
Where did I even hint at all that? I said that wealth redistribution is a Marxist ideal. Do you want to argue against that? You think that is not right? You can call it Marxist Theology if that makes you feel any better. There, you've got a label, is that what you wanted?
You think there are laws that protect people from wealth redistribution? Where is the law that protects us from a progressive income tax? What law would prevent B. Hussein Obama from enacting the wealth confiscation and redistribution that he is calling a windfall profits tax? Where is the law that stops the government from taxing the money I made from working and giving it to a high school dropout drug dealer in New Orleans? Where are those laws, nono? |
So would not charity be considered wealth redistribution?Are you saying Marx's introduce the Idea of Charity? You have yet to explain to me what school of marxism Obama is using?As for your tax laws I have no clue.and I am not researching them. |
Soapweed's answer was right on.
I said you could call it Marxist Theory, if that somehow makes a difference
You're the one who said there were laws. Was there any basis for you to say that?
|
|
| Back to top |
|
nonothing
Rancher
Joined: 12 Feb 2006
Posts: 2295
Location: bc
|
| Posted: Mon Sep 08, 2008 10:27 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Sandhusker wrote: |
| nonothing wrote: |
| Sandhusker wrote: |
Where did I even hint at all that? I said that wealth redistribution is a Marxist ideal. Do you want to argue against that? You think that is not right? You can call it Marxist Theology if that makes you feel any better. There, you've got a label, is that what you wanted?
You think there are laws that protect people from wealth redistribution? Where is the law that protects us from a progressive income tax? What law would prevent B. Hussein Obama from enacting the wealth confiscation and redistribution that he is calling a windfall profits tax? Where is the law that stops the government from taxing the money I made from working and giving it to a high school dropout drug dealer in New Orleans? Where are those laws, nono? |
So would not charity be considered wealth redistribution?Are you saying Marx's introduce the Idea of Charity? You have yet to explain to me what school of marxism Obama is using?As for your tax laws I have no clue.and I am not researching them. |
Soapweed's answer was right on.
I said you could call it Marxist Theory, if that somehow makes a difference
You're the one who said there were laws. Was there any basis for you to say that? |
So A Marxist theory is your answer?typical conservative answer..paint it with a big enough brush and your bound to cover your ass..
The Laws i wrote about were Labor Laws....the workers now have rights and laws to protect them from the rule of industrial ownership.In Marx's days they had no such laws....As I said Marx's ideas are base during the 1800's...
|
|
| Back to top |
|
|
